Cover Pump vs Manually Draining a Pool Cover
An automatic cover pump vs manually pumping or siphoning water off a pool cover: cover damage, safety, winter weight and effort.
The short version
Water pooling on a winter cover is heavy, and enough of it will tear the cover, pull the anchors or collapse it into the pool. An automatic pump switches itself on and keeps the cover clear without you thinking about it. Buy the pump if you cover the pool over winter, because a torn cover costs many times more.
At a glance
| Little Giant Automatic Cover Pump, 1700 GPH | Skimmer Socks, 50 Pack | |
|---|---|---|
| Runs unattended | Yes, automatic switch | No |
| Prevents cover damage | Yes | Only if you keep up |
| Winter freeze risk | Reduced | Water sits and freezes |
| Effort | None once set | Regular attention |
| Cost | Moderate | None |
| Also a safety issue | Water on a cover is a drowning hazard | Same |
Choose the Little Giant Automatic Cover Pump, 1700 GPH if…
You use a winter cover. Rain and snowmelt accumulate faster than people expect, and standing water on a cover is both a structural risk and a genuine drowning hazard for small children and pets, who can be trapped under a sagging cover.
Check Little Giant Automatic Cover Pump, 1700 GPH on Amazon
Choose the Skimmer Socks, 50 Pack if…
Reducing what lands on and in the pool in the first place means less of everything downstream. Socks and a cover work together rather than competing.
Check Skimmer Socks, 50 Pack on Amazon
Related
Comparison based on published manufacturer specifications and the general consensus of owner reports. We have not tested these products side by side. Confirm current specifications and prices before buying. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is water on a pool cover dangerous?
Yes, seriously. Even a few inches is heavy, and a child or animal that walks onto a covered pool can become trapped beneath the sagging material. Keep covers taut and drained.
Will the pump run dry?
Automatic models sense water and switch off, which is the reason to buy one rather than a manual utility pump. Check the model's minimum water depth for switching.
What about freezing?
Pumps can be damaged by freezing solid. In hard-freeze regions many owners remove the pump during deep cold and manage the cover differently, so check your model's guidance.
Taking care of a pool?
Use our free calculators and guides to get every number right.
Pool Care Planner: $39